Harry Potter vs. Nita and Kit

[CarynG]

Nita and Kit will win. It's not that I don't like Harry Potter, because I do, and I'm fairly obsessed. Still, YW is somehow more important because it's more like the real world. Except the fact that in YW there's wizardry, it's not something that there's just an endless amount of like in HP. In YW, everything has a price, so it's not as trivial.

[Dragon Writer]

posicat said:
Motivation : Why would they fight? This one's a little easier to imagine, the Lone Power is crafty, and from one side or the other he could surely corrupt some into fighting for his side.

Since this is fiction, and the YW wizardry is given to good wizards to fight entropy, that would imply the HP wizards were the evil ones to be battled. Good almost always ends up winning, in the end, even if by a slim margin.

well, it could be even simpler then that. (which is good because that would mean that nita and kit or harry potter got corrupted.) The LP could have simply tricked one, or both, of them into thinking the other one is evil.

[InkSlinger]

humph. i think hp's ok, but neets and kit so outrate him. and besides, it would never work to put their univeres together. ever seen that episode of both jimmy neutron and fairly odd parents? sucks!!

[PosiCat]

They're all good guys! They wouldn't fight each other!

It's an interesting question, and there would be some differences to work out before such a battle could take place.

Universe : The universe of HP and that of YW, especially pertaining to how magic works are different. The HP universe seems to specialize in canned spells, that is using one or two word phrases to cast a spell someone else put together. In YW the wizards are free to customize spells, and tinker, to understand what's going on behind the scenes. Still, if you assume the HP spells are just pre-defined YW spells (perhaps woven into the wands), the universes could be compatable enough for a battle.

Motivation : Why would they fight? This one's a little easier to imagine, the Lone Power is crafty, and from one side or the other he could surely corrupt some into fighting for his side.

Since this is fiction, and the YW wizardry is given to good wizards to fight entropy, that would imply the HP wizards were the evil ones to be battled. Good almost always ends up winning, in the end, even if by a slim margin.

[kaiba4ever]

I'm one of those sadistic creeps that put down "they'll all die!" Just kidding...

I really have no idea who'd win. Nita and Nit have their magic (which I think is waaay cooler than Harry Potter magic, must admit), but than Harry has his magic too. It really seems like Nita and Kit's magic is stronger, but I don't want to underestimate Harry, and it's not like he doesn't know how to put up a fight. I really must say... that I'm not sure... so therefore it's a draw. They tie.

[Cassi]

Although most of us might be a little biased here. After all this is the YW boards.... I reckon they would tie. Mainly because I can't decide. I love them all!

[Dragon Writer]

Ok, don't beat me up for this, but I think they might actually tie. *wards off several punches with spell* Suprisingliy enough, i've actually got a reason for this. ok, firSt off, if you want to be realistic, which, judging by several of your poste about the realism of yw, you do, their worlds are so differant that, for them to even fight they would have to be an another world, where both the magic of harry potter and the wizardry of Young Wizards would work, the differences of which would most likly through them off to an extent to make them doing any of this difficult, at best, impossible, at worst. Then, If they did do battle, there magic is so different it's hard to really compare them, but if you did, chances are they really would tie. I mean, his one word spells would hit them too fast to use anything other then ready made spells, plus they'd get tired and he'd still be going strong, what with the way their respective magic and wizardry work. at the same time, their spells are more powerful, and they have more experiance. chances are, eventually, nita and kit would run out of power, and harry would get tired of throwing useless spells at their shields, so they'd tie. I mean lets face it, their worlds are just to different for them to really battle.

[bluesalamanders]

I agree with Alla. The Harry Potter books aren't even in the same league as the YW series, in, basically, anything; plot, characterization, even (or especially) writing. YW is just so clearly superior. And the types of magic are so totally different.

Besides...I've never understood the point of questions like this...

They're all good guys! They wouldn't fight each other!

Blue

[kittymeow]

It's definetly a tough desision. I mean Harry Potter is such a powerful wizard. But then again, with Nita and Kit piared together, Harry Potter would probobly be no match for them. I mean if it were like just nita, or just kit against him, they would totally loose. But paired together, theres just no contest!

[ShadowWizard]

It's sort of a tough question. Though I'm in favor of Nita and Kit it could be a tie because both groups use magic. Acutally I think it would lean in favor of the YW wizards because Nita has her charm bracelet and both can use the partical excellerator(sp? right name for the weapon?) and just blast him but I dont think they would because it would speed up entropy. They also have most of their best magic ready to be used with one syllable, though HP just has to say one word too. So Im not sure who would win.

[Morana]

While I love the Harry Potter books, I think that Nita and Kit would win. I find Harry to be a very unremarkable wizard who seems to just get lucky a lot. While Nita and Kit have thwarted the Lone Power numerous times. Harry would so get his butt kicked.

[alla]

Hmm... interesting poll. I'm not going to vote in it as I believe that the two series are in different leagues. Very different leagues. One of the series is well written, and the other is, well... written.

On the other hand however, most of the people who have posted in this thread have been eaten by Poot. Please make your posts longer, as our forum demon is starting to feel rather full.
For those of you who are new here, Dai'stiho and welcome, just remember that DD acutually pays for the boards our of Her own pocket. As such, please make each post count. Please take time to read the FAQs in the Newbie Zone.

Alla

[the_peridexis]

OH COME ON!!! it's true, YW's magic makes more sense, but DON'T BE HATIN'!!! i love harry!

MY sister went to Alaalid and came back happy. i was miserable for weeks because of it.(beat that!!!)

[Frivs]

ahhh, I am surrounded by HP haters!! See now, Harry would win, because all he'd have to do is cast immobulous and they'd both be down on the ground...or stupify, that would work, too...yes, I am a Harry Potter fan, alright?? But I still love the Young Wizards *huggles Neets and Kit*

[Ben's Wizpod]

Nita and Kit would totaly win. Harry'd cast some spell and Neets'd do that gauntlet thing, and Harry'd be on the ground, begging for mercy.

-Ben