Harry Potter vs. Nita and Kit

[alla]

but rather, the Enterprise was the Federation, who were the Good Guys; while the Death Star was the Empire, who were the Bad Guys...

So it would be done in a two parter over the end of a season. The Death Star would appear to win at the end of the first episode and then the Enterprise would pull through in the end.

... sorry.. I'm in a _really_ strange mood...

[Kathy Li]

luv2read, the debate I mentioned would have been about 15 or 16 years ago. Back before the new Star Wars flicks came out. And it was mostly settled when someone pointed out that it wasn't a matter of who had warp drives vs. lightspeed engines, or big guns vs. phasers vs. photon torpedos, but rather, the Enterprise was the Federation, who were the Good Guys; while the Death Star was the Empire, who were the Bad Guys...

[luv2read]

Originally posted by kli6:
Cf, you're joking, right? PM is one of the biggest HP fans I know!

My big question would be: why would they fight each other? I figure they'd all be friends--especially Nita and Hermione.

(and why am I reminded of a three-week long USENET rec.arts.sf endless debate about "Who'd win--the Enterprise? Or the Death Star?"...)

Death star?!?! I LOVE star wars! is there really a topic on that?!?!
Sorry PM, getting of the subject...picky picky moderators...

[Peter Murray]

Ginny vs Dairine...

... the duel of the redheaded girls...

... presumably they're both allowed their pets, so Ginny has her Pygmy Puff and Dairine has Spot. It'll be a little unbalanced, won't it?

[Kathy Li]

"The only girls in their group"? Ginny and Dairine don't count?

Yes, they could be overshadowed by You-Know-Who/the Lone Power, but somehow it seems highly unlikely that their friends wouldn't have noticed and done something about it.

[Countryfan1394]

Sorry bout that PM didn't know and yes I am cracy about harry potter.
posted by kli6

I figure they'd all be friends--especially Nita and Hermione.

well of couse they'd be friends they're the only girls in their group. but LP could overshawod one of them or be a avatoir of one of one of the ppl. they could try to get LP out but that would be hard to get that done.

Country Music!!!

[Kathy Li]

Cf, you're joking, right? PM is one of the biggest HP fans I know!

My big question would be: why would they fight each other? I figure they'd all be friends--especially Nita and Hermione.

(and why am I reminded of a three-week long USENET rec.arts.sf endless debate about "Who'd win--the Enterprise? Or the Death Star?"...)

[Countryfan1394]

PM DON'T BE HATIN' ON HARRY!!
Well any ways it would be a tie because nita and kit woulgd run out of power. And harry would just tyred of blocking plus the question is why would they be figthing.
but there sould be a board saying what would happen if LP and Volamort( or however you spell it) worked together.

CountryMusic!!!

[Peter Murray]

Oddly, I don't find that DD's books hook me in. It always takes me several pages to really get into any of her books the first time I read it, and I have no idea why. But they've always been worth continuing with anyway.

Um, and back to the topic: this is the YW forum, so Nita and Kit would win . Besides, they outnumber Harry, unless he brings his friends.

[Cari]

Well, I once started to read HP, but read a couple pages, then got bored. DD hooks you right in, and keeps the reader's attention I'm not saying that JK Rowlings (or however you spell it) doesn't, I just haven't been interested enough to read her books. I love YW, and I'm just gonna leave it at that.

Well, I think it would be Nita and Kit who would win....duh! I haven't read Harry Potter, though, so I guess I shouldn't be takling. But, I HAVE seen most of the movies... Neets and Kit should have a movie! Ok, anyway, in HP, there isn't prices to pay for wizardry, and the spells are a lot shorter to say, like on a short notice when someone decides to attack you. On the other hand... in YW, you can prepare a spell in the back of your mind, and have it for later when you can say the last word. Also, YW has a universal (and beyond)languange, which can be used to talk to any wizard, or anyone who knows it. In HP, you become a wizard (or witch) because your parents were. In YW, you get chosen be the powers that be, which I think is better. Plus, in HP, it is just more fantasy and less likely to ever happen. YW takes place in pretty much modern world, and it makes you wonder if there really are wizards out there.

Merged two posts - Peter

[Frivs]

hey! I love HP and I am not immature! *wanders off to play with her Furby*

(seriously though, you can't really compare the two, they're two completely different styles of writing. I find the ability to enjoy two books without constantly trying to compare them and decide which is better very mature.)

[A F]

The YW far exceeds HP in every possible way. More immature people may prefer HP, but any smart person can see that YW is better.

[Adbelliveau]

Well, you can't really gauge them against each other. I mean, even though they're both about wizards, they're completely different.

In the same way, the Lone Power and Voldemort are two totally different bad guys (I think they'd kill each other before too long...assuming powers can die.

[Countryfan1394]

I will not say who will win or why! because it would take too long to explainbut be realistic ppl who win and why they would fight.

also will someone please start a place to post ro see what would happen if LP and Vodamort(or

however you spell it) worked together.

[matthew]

Well, its hard to say... I'm a huge fan of both HP and YW, but I'd say that most likely HP would win. HP's spells are only one or two words, and nita and kits are-unless they're ready made- paragraphs long. Evan the ready made ones can take a while- to decide which one, etc. I still Love the young wizards though!!!